Attack Of The Clones: Master and Padawan

“Why do I get the feeling you’re going to be the death of me?” – Obi-Wan Kenobi
“Don’t say that, master. You’re the closest thing I have to a father.”  — Anakin Skywalker

Hearing this exchange for the first time as a soon-to-be thirteen-year-old, I was dramatically shook. I mean the irony nearly bowled me over – I remember thinking, “No Obi, you don’t understand, HE IS GOING TO KILL YOU!” It’s one of those great little moments in the films where Star Wars itself goes a bit meta and speaks directly to the fans.

The relationship between Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker is something that drives the entire saga. In A New Hope we first hear Obi-Wan’s admittedly skewed version of events before we see them meet as enemies, duel, and watch in horror as we lose our first big SW hero when Darth Vader strikes down a willing Obi-Wan. This is in effect one of our true first moments of seeing how far Vader will go as a villain, Tarkin was the one that ordered the destruction of Alderaan, but Vader killed our beloved mentor Obi-Wan Kenobi.

And even after this point their lives were entwined as Obi-Wan returned as a Force Ghost to help Yoda train Luke as a Jedi, preparing him to face and kill Darth Vader, Luke’s own father. It’s only after Luke calls him on his falsehoods, that Obi-Wan admits the full truth, but defends his previous story in true Jedi manipulative fashion, saying he told the truth, “from a certain point of view.”

So, after all the events and drama of the original trilogy and the very limited time they shared in The Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones was the first time we truly got to see this epic pair together before Anakin became Vader and Obi-Wan’s story gets a bit fuzzy. And it’s truly so Shakespearian. We ALL KNOW Anakin is going to kill Obi-Wan someday, we’ve already seen it happen, but here they are onscreen with a relationship that although complicated, is full to the brim with love and affection. It makes it so much more difficult to see them as friends knowing how their story ends, but that’s really what makes the saga itself so effective. If they had hated each other from the get-go then we wouldn’t really care that Vader killed Obi-Wan, but that’s not the case at all, and so when the inevitable happens, we suffer along with the characters.

At the end of TPM Obi-Wan fulfills Qui-Gon’s dying wish to train Anakin, even going so far as to threaten the Council with disobedience, but we’re left with the knowledge that Anakin was not Obi’s choice. Would he resent his new responsibility to train a boy he didn’t know and had no real connection to, is that what would drive them apart and lead them to the deathly events of A New Hope? But then we see them together at last in the elevator in Attack of the Clones and immediately, the sense of warmth and familiarity sweeps over us. Obi-Wan may not have chosen Anakin and may never have on his own, but he truly loves Ani, and Ani loves him in return.

In this movie especially we see their relationship as Master and Padawan, or rather Father and Son. From the get-go we see Obi-Wan trying to instill wisdom and the Jedi mentality and Anakin bristling under the constant scrutiny. They bicker and push at each other constantly, but beneath it all is the truth that Anakin so easily admitted.

“You’re the closest thing I have to a father.”  — Anakin Skywalker

Watching AOTC again as an adult, I see not only the aggravation that Anakin feels at being judged, commented on, and critiqued constantly, but the absolute fear that Obi-Wan feels about Anakin. Obi-Wan knows the members of the Council rejected Anakin, he knows they don’t want him in their ranks and yet they’re forced to accept his presence. He understands that unlike any-other Jedi before him, Anakin has no true allies amongst the Jedi other than himself, and that without him Ani would truly be alone and at the mercy of the Jedi Masters. He respects the Council of Masters as his peers and comrades in the Force, but he truly loves Anakin, and in that love, resides great fear of what will happen to Anakin when he’s no longer protected with Padawan-status.

I think that fear leads him to push Anakin, to constantly keep at him and press his own mentality and character onto his student because that’s the only way he knows to keep Anakin safe. If he could make Ani enough like himself then the Council wouldn’t feel so threatened, they like Obi-Wan, so therefore they would like an Obi-Wan-esque Anakin. But that’s not possible. Anakin’s personality is too set to be changed, and his destiny wouldn’t allow for it anyway. He is who he is and although he respects and love Obi-Wan he doesn’t like the constant strain of always being wrong or being labeled as second-best. He wants to shine, but Obi-Wan is terrified of what will happen if he does. Again, it’s so Shakespearian, Obi-Wan tries to protect Anakin but it only leads to resentment and in effect, drives a wedge between Master and Padawan.

In the end, I think we see a great foundation formed in Attack of the Clones. Anakin and Obi-Wan are almost nothing like we’d expect them to be after seeing the Original Trilogy, they aren’t enemies but rather a small family unit with tangible real-world problems. There’s such an abundance of love between them and it makes the story so much more relatable and heartbreaking knowing that their fates are already set in stone. Obi-Wan will die. Vader will kill him. But for now, they are family, they protect each other and face the same issues all families do – just on a galactic level. But more than anything, there is Obi-Wan’s fear for his Padawan, fear for his son, that one day he will not be there to protect Anakin when he needs to be. And Anakin interprets this fear as any teenager would: as judgement and understandably bristles as being so undervalued. And even here, right at the beginning we see the cracks that are forming around them, setting the Force’s plan into motion. One day Anakin will fall, and not even Obi-Wan’s love will be enough to save him.

Media Via:

5 thoughts on “Attack Of The Clones: Master and Padawan

  1. Honestly… I never thought that Obi-Wan loved Anakin. He resented the heavy burden of having to raise and teach him without the help of the other Jedi, and he didn’t want to be blamed if things went awry.
    I think Ani was very close to the truth in AotC when he said to Padmé, in an emotional outburst, that Obi-Wan was holding him back because he envied him his superior powers. Obi-Wan did things I could never forgive him, like not allowing Ani to go save his mother, raise his weapon against him first (despite the “only for defense” code), and just leave him burning in the lava. Ani had killed Dooku at the beginning of RotS, an act of mercy. Obi-Wan struck me as someone wholly devoid of compassion. Just like Yoda or Mace Windu. The “protectors of peace” were only a group of stuck-up guys who cared more for themselves than for helping others.
    Ani had been taught compassion from his mother, and the Force sent him to the Jedi to remind him that they ought to be more like him; instead, they did all they could to destroy his compassionate nature. In the end, they created a monster and brought on their own extinction. They deserved nothing better.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I definitely agree with you about the nature and downfall of the Jedi, but Obi-Wan never stuck me that way. He seems a bit helpless and unsure of how to reach Ani sometimes but I’ve always seen a strong love between them. I think he could have initially resented having to teach Ani without really having an option to do otherwise with his promise to Qui-Gon, but I think that faded into a very complex and loving bond between them. And I definitely don’t see Ani killing Dooku as an act of mercy, but I love looking at things a new way, so what makes you think it was mercy and not resentment or anger that moved Ani?


  2. Dooku had lost both his hands and he was looking at him begging for mercy. And Anakin was still compassionate. His natural instinct was always to help and to protect. In the same scene he carries the unconscious Obi-Wan on his shoulders although Palpatine (whom he still believes to be a Jedi) tells him to leave him to his fate. He prefers to disobey than to do so.
    I can’t recall one instance where Obi-Wan or any of the other Jedi acted with compassion, though Yoda had said in TPM that compassion was central to their lives.
    And why did Anakin obsess so over Padmé? Because she was all he had. He felt that Obi-Wan did not trust him, and neither did the Jedi. And he never understood why they feared him so; he had given up everything to become one of them. He was lonely, had literally no one but her. Had he had only one true good friend, he would not have been so obsessed about her. Then Palpatine seemed to understand him and to offer him help and he thought he had found someone to rely on at last.
    I know that most fans believe Obi-Wan to be wise and to have been Ani’s friend, but to me’s that’s a big misconception. Obi-Wan is to me the embodiment of the wrong attitude of the Jedi: he does not mean evil, but he is too convinced to be right. And like the others he does not know how to love. The Jedi deliberately took small children from their families and taught them inner detachment. When Ani first comes to them he feels love for his mother, Qui-Gon and Padmé. And they are so distorted that they believe the capacity love to be sick, or dangerous. (Argh.)
    Yoda later warns him that too strong attachment is dangerous. But that’s the point: passion (obsessive love) is wrong, not compassion (selfless love). Anakin fell for obsessive love and redeemed himself for selfless love. And his obsession came from his loneliness, from the knowledge that he had nobody but Padmé who believed in the good in him.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I love the way you talk about Anakin because that’s exactly how I feel about his character! I see what you mean regarding Dooku although I still see it as less of a compassionate move and more of a giving in to anger but I can see where you’re coming from! And with Obi-Wan I’m always a little torn because I really like the prequel version, but the Original always came across as really shifty and pretty much an outright liar.


Any Thoughts? Let Me Know!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s